Blog Layout

The foundational reasons behind the Israel-Palestine conflict

Kelvin Crombie • Feb 15, 2024
Print Friendly and PDF

Editor's note: The Israel-Palestine conflict flared into a full war after Hamas brutally tortured and murdered more than 1,200 Israelis and kidnapped 253 more early on a Sabbath morning. Israel has since invaded Gaza in search of hostages and those responsible for the October 7 attack. Hamas reports as many as 28,000 Gazans have died; Hamas does not differentiate between its fighters and non-combatants.


The Israel-Hamas War is only the latest chapter in an ancient conflict. 


Below is an excerpt from Kelvin Crombie's paper “The foundational reasons behind the conflict in the land of (Eretz) Israel,” which sketches briefly the long history of the conflict. Download the whole paper as a PDF.


The current crisis in the land of Israel affects us all in different ways. Most of us in the West are shocked and even traumatized by the evil and brutality that occurred on 7th October 2023, which can only be described as a demonically inspired massacre.


Sadly, others have seized upon this act of pure brutality and made it a convenient platform on which to expound anti-Jewish and anti-Israel sentiment. As Israel endeavors to destroy the perpetrators of this heinous act of brutality and cowardice, such antisemitic and anti-Israel sentiment is bound to escalate.


I have personally witnessed, numerous times over the last forty plus years, how quickly the world forgets atrocities against Israelis, including murder, which precipitates a response and then focuses solely upon Israel’s response. This dynamic is even more significant when many ordinary people, in or out of the Church, seemingly pay little attention to terrible acts of violence throughout the Islamic and Arab-speaking world and get very agitated and opinionated when it comes to perceived and actual Israeli violence against the Palestinians. This is not negating the fact that many innocent Arab-speaking people in Gaza, Judea and Samaria do suffer and are caught up in the conflict – but there is most definitely an imbalance in people’s attitudes and responses, fed by the often-erroneous media reporting. Why is this so?

But, more importantly, why did this cowardly act of barbarism occur in the first place, and why has it so quickly escalated into an anti-Jewish and anti-Israel worldwide crusade? The main purpose of this paper is not to analyze the events of 7th October and the subsequent response of the Israeli government, as there are numerous other avenues covering these aspects, but to hopefully provide some broader background and context to the current crisis.


The Middle East situation is neither simple nor straightforward, especially to the western mindset. It is composed of many layers and is therefore quite complex and complicated, and cannot be even remotely understood unless one looks at these different layers. Some of these layers stretch back for thousands of years, while some are more recent. But all of these layers are connected. The very foundational layer relates to the cosmic battle between Almighty God and the adversary, named Satan, Lucifer or the devil, between the Kingdom of God and the kingdom of darkness. This brief analysis by no means covers all such layers, nor does it pretend to cover all aspects of those layers, although hopefully it might provide some comprehension to this dynamic, a dynamic that affects every person in the entire world.


My personal perspective is shaped by having lived in Israel altogether for some 25 years stretching between 1979-2009. While there I was introduced to Jesus, I met and married my wife there and my four children were all born there. 

Although most of my/our interaction was with Israeli Jews, yet there was considerable interaction with Arabic-speaking people, both Christian and Muslim. For one year I worked with physically handicapped Arabic-speaking and Jewish young adults and did all that was required in such a capacity. For three years in the mid-1980s I/we lived in what was then a totally Muslim village, Silwan (the City of David), while many of my work colleagues and staff in several work situations were Arabic-speaking people. Just as in any part of the world, there are pleasant and unpleasant Israeli Jews and there are pleasant and unpleasant Arabic-speaking peoples.


In the years before the first Intifada (an uprising of violence) against Israel inspired by the Arab leadership, which began in late 1987, I visited Gaza on numerous occasions, and even spent time walking through the refugee camps. Back then they were overcrowded and not at all pleasant places to visit, let alone to live in.


As a born-again follower of Jesus (John 3:1-17), I became somewhat aware of many of the spiritual dynamics associated with the Jewish people, Jerusalem, Islam and the land of Israel, and particularly of the principles of covenant.


What unfolded on Saturday 7th October can never be understood at the physical level as it is a spiritual conflict at the highest level. Unless there is some comprehension of these spiritual dynamics, then it is well-nigh impossible to comprehend the conflict on the ground. Paul, Moses and Jeremiah summarized the matters at hand:


  • For we do not wrestle against flesh and blood, but against principalities, against powers, against the rulers of the darkness of this age, against spiritual hosts of wickedness in the heavenly places (Ephesians 6:12)

  • Then the LORD God saw that the wickedness of man was great in the earth, and that every intent of the thoughts of his heart was only evil continually (Genesis 6:5)

  • The heart is deceitful above all things, and desperately wicked; Who can know it? (Jeremiah 17:9)


There is a spiritual conflict of the highest order over the land of Israel. This battle is over the accomplishment of the purposes of Almighty God for worldwide redemption and the attempts by God’s adversary to hinder and thwart the accomplishment of this grand plan. Central to this plan are the dual themes of covenant and the heart of humankind.



Read the rest of the paper (PDF)


Kelvin Crombie is an Australian who lived in Israel for almost twenty-five years and worked for CMJ Israel for many years as a guide, manager, and author. Kelvin has written many books and produced documentaries on the work of the Church's Ministry Among Jewish People, Christ Church Jerusalem, the ANZACs, and Jewish Christians in the Holocaust. Kelvin lives in Perth, Australia, with his Dutch wife Lexie. They have four adult daughters.

Blessed by this post? Ready to sow into the work of CMJ? No gift is too small. we are blessed by your partnership.



Give
By CMJ staff 14 Apr, 2024
As the Israel-Hamas War wages on, CMJ Israel continues to find ways to do life and ministry amidst the strife, turmoil, and lack.
By Carino Casas 12 Apr, 2024
The Prophets were expecting another redemption and a time when Torah would be written on hearts rather than stone. Jesus initiates the new covenant of Jeremiah 31:31 at his last Passover seder with his disciples.
By Carino Casas 12 Apr, 2024
Jewish Media Review - April 2024
More Posts
Share by: