There are more Jewish believers in Jesus than you think

Carino Casas • April 14, 2025
Print Friendly and PDF

Nearly 2 million Americans with Jewish background, according to Pew

After a church conference in Virginia last month, I stopped at a grocery store to pick up some wine for Sabbath. I struck up a conversation with the cashier. I asked him how I could pray for him, and he said, "I pray. I'm a Muslim."

 

As we talked, he revealed he was from Eritrea and had studied Islam at university. He had read the Hebrew Bible and New Testament and bragged to me that he had talked Christians out of their faith.

 

So I asked him a question.

 

"I understand when Islam says Muhammad is The Prophet, you mean the Prophet like Moses (Deut 18:15ff). Is that correct?" "Yes," he replied.

 

"The Gospel writers, particularly Matthew, show that Jesus is the the Prophet like Moses, "I continued. "That is what Christianity believes."

 

"Which verse?" he asked defiantly, ready to refute me.

 

"Not one verse," I said, "but the whole book of Matthew shows Jesus as the Prophet like Moses."

 

"No. Jesus is a prophet but not The Prophet," the cashier replied. "And, besides, Jews have not believed in Jesus."

 

"There are Jews who believe in Jesus," I told him. "Not all of them, but their are Jews who believe in Jesus as Messiah." He didn't believe me.

 

I encouraged him to read Matthew with fresh eyes. We blessed each other and parted with a handshake.

 

There are indeed Jewish believers in Jesus, more than we may believe.


 

In 2020, Pew Research released their report on Jewish Americans. In it, they found that there are 5.8 million Jewish adults in the United States and another 2.8 million Americans who have Jewish background (one Jewish parent but weren't raised Jewish).

 

Of the nearly 6 million Jewish adults, 27 percent were raised Jewish but now consider themselves something else. Of those, 19 percent say they are Christians. That's nearly 300,000 Jewish believers in Jesus.

 

Of the 2.8 million Americans who have Jewish background (but were not considered Jewish in the report), 52 percent are Christian, 4 percent are Messianic Jews, and 1 percent consider themselves both Jewish and Christian. That totals 1.6 million Jewish-background Americans who believe in Jesus.

 

That's nearly 2 million followers of Jesus who have Jewish DNA, just in the United States.

 

So next time some one tells you, "Jews don't believe in Jesus," let them know that at least 1.9 million people disagree.


Invite us to speak on the history of Jewish believers in Jesus!

Blessed by this post? Ready to sow into the work of CMJ? No gift is too small. we are blessed by your partnership.



Give
By The Forward September 3, 2026
Bedouin shepherds found it. A bishop sold it. An Israeli agent bought it. Now you can see it up close.
By Carino Casas August 25, 2026
2026 has been a remarkable year of connection for CMJ USA. Traveling across the country to meet so many of you in person—at churches, conferences, and gatherings—is always a highlight of our ministry. From our early trips through South Carolina, Georgia, and Florida to our upcoming visits in California, Texas, and Virginia (plus the meaningful Seders and teachings close to home in Pennsylvania), we are deeply grateful for every open door. As we look ahead, we are preparing for a major milestone: launching Emunah in 2027 and introducing it to congregations nationwide. To reach as many communities as possible, we need to build a strong digital and physical foundation today. Here is where your Day of Giving support directly makes an impact: Expanding Emunah: While Emunah will initially launch as a digital download, our goal is to expand into print editions and high-quality video instruction to maximize its reach. Travel & Outreach: Bringing the Jewish roots of our faith directly to local congregations requires flights, rental cars, and boots on the ground. Upgrading Our Digital Presence: We are optimizing our website to make key resources easily accessible and expanding CMJ’s voice on social media to actively counter anti-Jewish rhetoric with truth and clarity. How You Can Partner with Us Today Invite Us to Your Church: We would love to minister to your local congregation in person. Pray for the Ministry: Stand with us in prayer for wisdom, safe travels, and open doors. Invest in the Mission: Consider becoming a monthly donor or giving a strategic one-time gift this Day of Giving. As Director Emeritus Philip Bottomley often reminds us, "The Lord pays for what He orders." We also know He delights in using His saints as conduits of His abundant provision. To our faithful regular donors: thank you. You are integral to everything we do. Will you help us take this next step forward today?
By CMJ Staff August 18, 2026
CMJ USA visits Christ Church Midland with New Wineskins Anglican Partners
More Posts